In the tech community, where innovation often meets consumer expectations in a digital marketplace, Marques Brownlee, widely known by his YouTube handle MKBHD, has ventured beyond video reviews into the realm of software with his wallpaper app called Panels for both iOS and Android. However, the New Jesery-based tech cricts’s latest venture has not met with the acclaim one might expect from a tech guru of Brownlee’s stature. Instead, it has sparked a wave of criticism from users regarding its usability, permissions, and pricing.
ALSO READ: Google is now rolling out Gemini Live to all Android users for free
The app, designed to offer high-quality, dynamic wallpapers inspired by MKBHD’s channel, was intended to bring visually stunning backgrounds to users’ devices. However, recent feedback, especially from posts on X (formerly known as Twitter), indicates a less-than-favorable reception. Users have expressed frustration over several aspects:
1. Cost: One of the primary grievances is the app’s pricing model. For an app primarily offering aesthetic enhancements like wallpapers, the $49.99 per year cost seemed steep to many, especially when compared to similar offerings in the app market some of which are free. While premium content often commands a premium price, the expectation from an app linked to a figure like MKBHD was perhaps for a more accessible or justified pricing structure.
2. Permissions: The app requires an array of permissions that have raised eyebrows. Users have questioned why a wallpaper app needs access to such a broad spectrum of device functionalities. This concern isn’t just about privacy but also about the principle of what permissions an app genuinely needs versus what it asks for. This has led to discussions on overreach, even if the permissions are standard for many apps in today’s digital ecosystem.
3. User Experience: The functionality and user interface of the app have also come under scrutiny. Users reported issues ranging from the app’s performance, lack of intuitive design, to problems with wallpaper updates or customization options not working as expected. For an app associated with MKBHD, known for his meticulous reviews and high standards, these complaints highlight a disconnect between the brand’s reputation and the product’s execution.
4. Community Reaction: The tech community, particularly active on platforms like X, has been vocal about their disappointment. A notable X post from @ianzelbo, which humorously highlighted the absurdity of some app permissions, captured the sentiment well.
This post and others reflect not just criticism but a sense of betrayal or at least surprise from fans who expected better from MKBHD ‘s first major software venture. Marques Brownlee, in response to the backlash, took to X to address the concerns. His statement was a mix of acknowledgment of the feedback and a defense of the app’s intentions. He emphasized the app’s design to provide high-quality, unique content, suggesting that the high permissions were to ensure functionality across various device capabilities.
However, this response has not entirely quelled the discontent, with many users feeling that while intentions might have been good, execution and perhaps oversight in permissions and pricing were lacking. The situation with MKBHD’s wallpaper app brings to light several broader issues within the app development ecosystem: –
When tech influencers or celebrities venture into product development, there’s an implicit trust in their brand. Users expect not just quality but also an ethical consideration in how their data and money are handled. MKBHD’s app seems to have not fully met these expectations and was dead on arrival. Some comments have come out to with memes such as “That one guy in class who lectures everyone but scores 0 in exam” as shown in the tweet below.
While MKBHD’s venture into app development was ambitious, aiming to merge his passion for tech with user experience, it’s apparent that the transition from being a reviewer to a developer isn’t seamless. The criticisms over cost, permissions, and functionality highlight the complexities of market expectations, privacy concerns, and the challenge of maintaining brand integrity in new ventures. This episode might well serve as a lesson in the importance of aligning product design not just with functionality but with user trust and value perception in the digital age.
